PB&J Cookie

Regular price
Regular price
Sale price

Order PB&J Cookie Delivery

Peanut Butter Bliss

If anyone ever tells you that you can’t have cookies for lunch, then simply explain to them that they haven’t been Banged properly. Our PB&J stuffed cookies are hands-down the best peanut butter cookies ever made. And the reason is simple as a dimple: ours are 3 ingredient peanut butter cookies. Peanut Butter. Jam. Love. It’s true, you can Google it. These treats are bursting with a unique flavor that melds the tart with the succulent, the tangy with the Bang-y. 

Peanut Butter and Jelly Stuffed Cookie

Break open this peanut butter cookie and you immediately will see just what we’re talking about. The candied jam trickles out, as it refuses to be contained. Yes, this berry nice confection meshes swimmingly with our creamy organic peanut butter, cementing a match made in bakery heaven. This piquant peanut butter cookie will have you recalling your school days, making you desperately wish you ever had a packed lunch that tasted this dang good.


Bang Cookies baked goods are hand made using shared equipment which processes eggs, wheat, dairy, soy, peanuts, cashews, tree nuts, almonds, walnuts, pecans, coconuts, macadamia nuts, pistachios, hazelnuts. We try our best to prevent cross-contamination but if you have severe allergies please take note to the fact that we are not an allergy free bakery.

Shipping Info

Bang Cookies offers 3 ways to get your cookies:

• Shipping By Mail nationwide with FedEx and UPS

• Local Delivery with our drivers within the vicinity of our physical stores

• Pick Up directly from our store locations

Find out more shipping details.

Why everyone wants to get Banged!

Feedback from customers that have been banged!

Customer Reviews

Based on 456 reviews
Les C.

The peanut butter and Jelly cookie needs to have grape jelly or even raspberry jelly. Truthfully you need to have different flavors of the peanut butter and jelly cookie

Joy W.

Freaking best cookie I have ever had!!!


I bought 3 cookies at the Middletown Grange Fair in PA last weekend and loved each cookie even more than the one before! I got the Cinnamon Whiskey Crackle, Brownie Cookie and the PB & J….all I can say is….YUMMMM! We used to go to a local place that we thought had the best cookie, but I will be ordering from Bang from now on! Holy Moly are they delicious! Crispy on the outside and soft on the inside and drool worthy! I will also be buying these as gifts! Thank you Bang! My night started and ended with a Bang! 😜

Not bad!

I am usually not a fan of peanut butter cookies but like pb & j sandwiches. I tried this one because of the strawberry jam. Well, although I am still not a fan of peanut butter cookies, this one has won me over!! It was so moist and the pb flavor was not overpowering. I like this one!

Colleen N.
New Comfort Cookie

Probably my favorite cookie of theirs. It’s not overwhelming sweet which I was nervous about. The prentice cookie was perfect with just the right amount of jam in the middle. Definitely prefer one of these cookies to an actual PB&J