What a creative and yummy cookie
Both recipients said that these were the best cookies ever. Fascinated to scan many other products from this source.
Take care. Gail
Good balance of Pb&J.
These cookies are huge and delicious. I normally have no issue finishing off a gourmet cookie but these are large and filling! Just because they are big though doesn't mean you lose flavor; a nice peanut butter taste and the jelly was just right. I like jelly but not when it oozes out all over. These were perfect and I will be ordering again. These were bought for a vacation road trip and were just the right treat when the drive got old!
They were so soft and delightful . My husband has talked about them since we got them.
I only have 4 stars because I wish they had more jelly in them.
What stole the show for me was the sea Salt chocolate chunk cookies. OH.MY. HEAVENS.
I’ve been very happy with all of the things we have ordered so far.
The cookies were sent as a gift to my sister's family. The PB & J was universally adored (and grudgingly shared).
Banging to say the least!
They looked great- unfortunately we weren’t able to eat them as we traveled with them in a cooler and since the packages weren’t sealed, water got in and ruined them we were devestated!! Hope to try them again someday soon. Hated to waste all that money on them and not even get to eat them!!
Even after freezing it and warming up it was good
A wonderful cookie. Better than any PB&J cookie I've had (and I have had a few). The moisture and size and outstanding flavor put it over the top!
Love love love you P&J cookies makes me smile lol
This was the most delicious cookie I have ever had
Cookie pretty good but a little soggy
I come from Europe so American cookies are not my first choice as other desserts mostly french always caught my attention! After trying bang cookies PB&J I had no words! I couldn’t stop eating! I even asked my family to eat the cookies so I wouldn’t!! It was the most amazing cookie ever, I can’t stop thinking of it and planning my next order!!! My next ORDERSSSSSS
The cookie itself came a little smashed but they tasted good! I'm sure they would have been 10x better if it hadn't taken 5 days to ship-
This is an amazing cookie. It's actually perhaps more like a cake since it does tend to be a bit messier than the average cookie.. but it's amazing!
This cookie left no surprises it is what it is amazing and gooey delicious!
Love these cookies. They are the best.
Jelly was very sweet and I like nutty peanut
So delicious!! Arrived the very next day... will definitely be ordering more. One of the best chocolate chip cookies I’ve ever had!
The cookies were absolutely amazing. Soft, super fresh & chewy and delicious down to the last chunky crumb.
I ordered these for a friend and she and her husband loved them! They said they want to order more. I loved how they arrived next day. Thank you.
Great flavor and tasted freshly baked. Would definitely buy again.
This cookie was delicious!! It had the right amount of peanut butter and jelly in it. My kids and I really enjoyed it and I will definitely order more of these soon.
These cookies are unbelievable! Peanut butter and jelly in a cookie! Yum!
think although so delicious, they are too big, seem more like a cake..i would reduce to cookie size, and slightly reduce price..
The were very good.
Absolutely fabulous a d delicious. Keep the new flavors coming. I like the packaging and the website too.
The cookies are of high quality, but for my taste, they perhaps try too hard. By that, I mean that they are laden with numerous ingredients to the point where nothing in particular stands out. A case in point: The smores cookie has marshmallow, but it is difficult to distinguish it from all the other parts of the cookie. Many people must like the kitchen sink approach, but I prefer something simpler.
oh my goodness. I think this has got to be hands down the best peanut butter cookie i’ve ever had. it isn’t dry like most, it’s soft but crumbly. it works. even better that there’s jam too.
Quick delivery and such tasty treats! I ordered these for a friend and he LOVED them!
Cookies were delicious and delivered on time.
Great one of the best cookies ever
Tried a few ‘flavors’ and the PB&J was the best! They were all delicious. Delivery was scheduled, on time, and great communication. Can’t wait to order again!
Not sure if maybe the type of jelly? Something was a tiny bit off.
SO god damn good. Fast service, great product. Salted caramel is the best! Make more flavors!!
The cookies are great. The sea salt chocolate chip is amazing. Even the oatmeal raisin is very good.
The PB&J cookie took me back to my childhood and all the fond memories I had of enjoying a nice PB&J from my mother
Cookie was a little awkward shape and too thick. Taste was good maybe try incorporating the jelly in a different way instead of sandwiched between cookie dough
This was my favorite of the cookies we ordered. A perfect balance of flavors and so yummy.
The cookies were amazing!!!
Perfect ingredients and a nice softer texture, super yummy!
I liked that it was a pbj in a cookie form. However, I felt that it was too sweet. I think less jam needed to have been included.
Loved the peanut butter! The jelly portion was very sweet but yummy. I would love a 100% PB cookie.
I don't usually review on individual sites, but this cookie was amazing! Tasted like eating a PB&J and a cookie at the same time. Lots of peanut butter taste and the jelly wasn't overpowering, great balance. My only warning/critique (which I don't think is even a big deal), since there is jelly in the middle, the cookie is very soft/crumbly.
So moist, so delicious!
The pb&j cookies taste as good as they look! They were delicious.
This cookie is amazing. I’ve never had anything like it.